2 min read
Published On12 Aug 2025
Colts Nation stretches way beyond Indiana’s borders! Whether you’re a transplant chasing career opportunities, a lifelong fan stuck in enemy territory, or just passing through and desperate to catch the game, tracking down legit Colts viewing spots outside Indy can be brutal. But hardcore fans have carved out little chunks of horseshoe heaven all across the map.
These joints get it – they understand why you’re still rocking that Peyton Manning jersey in 2025, and they respect the devotion that keeps you screaming through every heartbreaking season.
Coast to coast, these spots have either officially teamed up with Colts fan clubs or just naturally attracted enough Indy expats to create the real deal. The brotherhood among displaced fans is insane – you walk in wearing your colors and boom, instant family that shares your obsession.
We’re still fine-tuning our game plan & this is round one – drop us some intel to help nail down better recommendations and uncover more secret Colts hideouts nationwide!
New York Area
1. Keat's Bar
Ratings:
Notable Features:
- What Makes It Special: This Manhattan joint has earned serious street cred among Indy transplants hunting for authentic horseshoe experiences. Official Colts NYC headquarters since 2009! The Irsay family has been known to drop in when they're in town.
- Sports Setup: Multiple screens scattered throughout with audio they'll actually adjust for Colts games when you ask nicely. The setup handles different fan crews while delivering solid viewing action.
- Food & Drink: Standard sports bar grub with New York wallet-crushing prices but decent execution. The menu hits all the game day essentials that'll fuel hungry Colts fans through marathon viewing sessions.
- Atmosphere: New York hustle meets Midwest Colts passion. The spot draws both homesick Indy refugees and locals who've gotten sucked into the team through friends and relationships.
- Special Features: Official Colts NYC headquarters, Multiple TVs with Colts game priority, Karaoke every night for victory celebrations, Central Manhattan location in Midtown East.
Chicago Area
1. Four Shadows Tavern & Grill
Ratings:
Notable Features:
- What Makes It Special: Chicago sports bar that's blown up with Indy transplants and Colts fans. Known as THE Indianapolis Colts bar in Chicago! The venue provides neutral turf in Bears country for fans seeking authentic Indianapolis football experiences.
- Sports Setup: Multiple screens throughout the tavern with audio systems that handle various fan group demands. The setup ensures Colts fans get quality viewing despite being in hostile territory.
- Food & Drink: Tavern menu with Chicago-area pricing and Midwest comfort food that hits the spot for displaced Indy fans. Game day specials help manage costs for regular visits during football season. Their tots are legendary!
- Atmosphere: Neutral ground energy where Colts fans rally despite being deep in Bears territory. The venue attracts Indy transplants seeking community and authentic viewing experiences away from home. Great crowds on both Saturdays (Iowa Hawkeyes) and Sundays (Colts).
- Special Features: Official Colts fan gathering spot in Chicago, Multiple TVs throughout venue, Game day specials and promotions, Also home to Iowa Hawkeyes and Marquette Eagles fans.
2. Mullen's Sports Bar & Grill
Ratings:
Notable Features:
- What Makes It Special: Chicago establishment that's gained traction among Colts fans hunting reliable viewing experiences. Named after Chicago police officer Jim Mullen. The bar provides welcoming vibes for Indy transplants in Chicago's brutal sports market.
- Sports Setup: Solid sports viewing with multiple screens positioned for optimal angles from different seating areas. Audio can be adjusted to handle Colts fan requests during crucial games.
- Food & Drink: Bar and grill menu with Chicago standards for pricing and quality. The food selection covers game day favorites that satisfy hungry football fans during extended viewing marathons. Award-winning wings!
- Atmosphere: Welcoming environment for displaced Colts fans in Chicago's savage sports landscape. The venue has attracted regular following of Indy transplants seeking authentic viewing experiences.
- Special Features: Pool table and darts available, Multiple TVs with flexible audio, Family-oriented local tavern atmosphere.
Southeast
1. Fado Irish Pub
Ratings:
Notable Features:
- What Makes It Special: Irish pub in Atlanta that's pulled Indy transplants hunting authentic sports viewing experiences. The venue combines Irish pub atmosphere with American football viewing for a unique vibe.
- Sports Setup: Multiple screens throughout the Irish pub setting with audio that adjusts for American football games. The setup handles both soccer and NFL viewing preferences.
- Food & Drink: Irish & sports pub menu with Atlanta-area pricing and authentic prep. The combination of Irish fare and American sports creates unique dining experience during Colts games.
- Atmosphere: Irish pub character meets American football passion. The venue attracts both displaced Indy fans and locals seeking authentic pub experiences with sports viewing.
- Special Features: Traditional Irish pub atmosphere, Multiple viewing screens throughout, Full Irish menu and beer selection, Rooftop patio and beer garden.
Southwest
1. Tavern Grille Scottsdale
Ratings:
Notable Features:
- What Makes It Special: Scottsdale spot that's blown up with Indy transplants and retirees who bailed to Arizona. The tavern provides Midwest atmosphere in desert setting for displaced Colts fans.
- Sports Setup: Over 25 TVs throughout the venue with audio systems that handle various fan group preferences. The setup ensures solid Colts coverage despite the Arizona location. Off-track betting adds extra excitement.
- Food & Drink: Tavern menu mixing Southwest flavors with Midwest favorites. Arizona pricing with quality prep that satisfies both local residents and displaced Indy fans. Great happy hour specials daily. Week long specials and Happy Hour all-day on Sundays.
- Atmosphere: Midwest transplant energy in Arizona desert setting. The venue attracts Indy retirees and transplants seeking familiar sports viewing experiences in new territory.
- Special Features: 25+ TVs for comprehensive coverage, Off-track betting available, Daily specials and happy hour, Weekend breakfast service Saturday & Sunday.
West Coast
Finding authentic Colts viewing experiences outside Indianapolis requires dedication, but these venues prove that Colts Nation truly extends coast to coast. From the energy of New York sports bars to the transplant communities in Chicago, from Arizona retirement havens to West Coast tech centers, displaced fans have created pockets of blue and white passion across the country.
The bond among displaced Colts fans is special – there’s immediate connection when you find fellow horseshoe faithful thousands of miles from home.
Whether you’re a recent transplant missing Sunday traditions or a longtime displaced fan seeking authentic experiences, these locations provide genuine Colts viewing atmosphere that makes every game feel closer to home. The dedication of these venues to accommodate Indianapolis fans in competitive markets proves the strength and reach of Colts Nation.
This is our initial research into Colts bars outside the Indianapolis metro area, and we know there are many more hidden gems across the country. What’s your favorite Colts bar outside Indiana? Comment below and help us build a comprehensive guide for displaced fans everywhere – we want to make sure no Colts fan has to watch games alone, no matter where life has taken them!
Bibliography
Primary Sources:
- Indianapolis Colts Fan Groups Directory – “National Fan Club Information” – Research ongoing
- Displaced Sports Fans Networks – “Indianapolis Colts Viewing Locations” – Various online forums and social media groups
- Sports Bar Location Databases – “NFL Team Affiliated Venues” – Multiple city-specific directories
- Indianapolis Transplant Communities – “Social Media Group Recommendations” – Facebook and Reddit communities
- Travel and Sports Websites – “NFL Viewing Guides by City” – Various travel and sports publication resources
- Local Sports Bar Directories – “City-Specific Venue Information” – New York, Chicago, Phoenix, Atlanta, and San Francisco directories
- Fan Community Recommendations – “Word-of-Mouth Venue Suggestions” – Ongoing research through fan networks
- Professional Transplant Networks – “Alumni Association Viewing Parties” – University and professional organization resources
- Regional Sports Coverage – “Out-of-Market NFL Viewing Options” – Local sports media recommendations
- Social Media Fan Groups – “Colts Fans Nationwide Communities” – Facebook, Reddit, and other platform groups
Sign Up
